Contractors Inside IR35 – 31% | Contractors Outside IR35 – 54%

Government Contractors Inside IR35
Government Contractors Inside IR35

Contractors Inside IR35

The percentage of contractors inside IR35 is 31%.

The percentage of contractors outside IR35 is 54%.

This is according to a Freedom of Information request from ContractorCalculator.

This information comes from over half a million people using the Check Employment Status for Tax tool (CEST).

The test couldn’t determine the status of the other 15%.

Questions on Contractors Inside IR35

This article will answer the following questions:-

  1. What are the new Government IR35 Rules for Public Sector Bodies?
  2. Are Most Freelancers Tax Avoiders?
  3. Do Freelancers have more expenses and less benefits than permanent employees?
  4. Do Contractors No Longer decide their own IR3 5status?
  5. What is the Check Employment Status for Tax tool?
  6. Why are contractors joining Umbrella Companies?
  7. How will IR35 changes affect contractors working in the private sector?
  8. Are Public Sector Bodies Falsely Implementing IR35 changes?
  9. Will all contractors be inside IR35 in the future?

What are the New Government IR35 Rules for Public Sector Bodies

The background to this is in the Government’s new IR35 rules in the public sector.

They implemented this in all of their departments in April 2017.

Previously, all contractors and freelancers decided heir own IR35 status.

If they got it wrong,  HMRC could potentially chase them for back tax, penalties and interest.

However, there was safety in numbers.

There was more chance of lightning striking a contractor than being the object of an investigation for IR35.

Contractors inside IR35 were able to get away with it more easily.

They could always take out IR35 Insurance.

Are Most Freelancers Tax Avoiders?

The Government believe that most freelancers are tax avoiders.

This is shown by both Prime Minister Theresa May and the Chancellor saying that it was an unfair anomaly that a self employed person earning £100,000 a year pays less tax and national insurance contributions than an employee earning £100,000 a year.

They aim to fix this ‘unfair anomaly’.

Do Freelancers Have More Expenses and Less Benefits Than Permanent Employees

Of course, everyone who freelances knows that it is not comparing like with like.

Permanent Employees get a lot more benefits than contractors.

They are also in safer positions than contractors.

So, there should be a risk premium in being a contractor.

There are also expenses that freelancers have that permanent employees don’t have.

However, the Government decided that they would change the IR35 rules in their own departments.

Do Contractors No Longer Decide Their own IR35 Status

They would change who decided a contractor’s IR35 status in the public sector.

The contractor would no longer decided his or her own IR35 status.

The Government department hiring them would decide this – the Public Sector Body or PSB as they refer to it.

The Government’s idea is tat it would catch contractors inside IR35.

What is the Check Employment Status for Tax Tool

They would use HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax tool (CEST) to determine a freelancer’s true IR35 status.

If the freelancer passed the test then HMRC said they would accept this result.

The freelancer could continue to use a Personal Service Company (PSC) as he or she did previously.

However, if they failed the test, the fee-payer, in most cases their agency, would have to deduct tax and National Insurance before paying the contractor.

However, many smaller agencies are not set up to deal with this.

Why are Contractors Joining Umbrella Companies

So, in practice, most contractors inside IR35, who failed the CEST test, joined umbrella companies.

Previously, more than 90% of contractors operated through personal service companies with most of the rest using umbrella companies.

Now, as we see, only 54% of contractors get a clean bill of health for IR35.

One would assume that in the case of the 15% where there is no clear verdict of whether a contractor is inside IR35 or outside, according to the test, most employers would not take a chance.

So, one would expect that 54% of contractors could still operate via Personal Service Companies whereas 46% could not.

That’s pretty close to a toss-up.

One would expect that the vast majority of those who took the test are those who work for Public Sector Bodies.

How Will IR35 Changes Affect Contractors Working in the Private Sector

However, there’s no reason to believe that the numbers would be different for freelancers working in the private sector.

Although this has been implemented only by Public Sector Bodies so far, it will be implemented in the private sector too in April 2020.

They announced it in the 2018 budget and implement it in April 2020.

After all, if Theresa May thinks it is unfair that self employed people who earn £100,000 a year pay less tax than permanent employees earning £100,000 a year, she is hardly likely to believe that this is only unfair in the public sector and not the private sector.

Are Public Sector Bodies Falsely Implementing IR35 Changes

The problem has been made worse by some Public Sector Bodies falsely implementing these IR35 rule changes.

Every contractor is supposed to be tested separately.

However, one public sector contractor in the NHS told us that he and two colleagues were tested at the same time.

The project manager input the details.

However, he kept being interrupted by the woman from HR who reversed his verdict on some of the questions.

As you can imagine, none of these changes favoured the contractor.

Blanket Ban on Contractors Using Personal Service Companies

Also, some like the MoD and NHS had a blanket ban on using contractors who operated through personal service companies.

Contractors that they currently use had to change their way of operating.

That was even though many of them were actually outside IR35 and could pass the CEST test.

The major consultancies, who would benefit from the demise of the contracting profession, were advising them to do this.

Now major banks and finance companies like Barclays, RBS, HSBC, Lloyds, Morgan Stanley and M&S Investments are going to have blanket bans on limited company contractors.

Will All Contractors Be Inside IR35 in the Future

They said it was too risky as contractors who passed the test now might be found to be caught by IR35 in the future if the rules changed.

This is ridiculous – but risk averse Government department managers and major banks decided to take this advice.

Unless IPSE’s and others lobbying efforts work then the Government will implement this in the private sector too. This will be in April 2020.

Many contractors who currently use Personal Service Companies will no longer be able to use them.

This will lead to a significant drop in their income.

Will one of these contractors be you?

Take the test here – IR35 Status Test for Contractors

If you know anyone else who would find this article useful, please share it with them using the social media buttons at the top and bottom of the page.

Ad – Contractor Services

When the IR35 changes were implemented in the public sector, rather than just pay the IR35 tax, most contractors inside IR35 decided to take the umbrella company route. If you are inside IR35, or caught by a blanket ban on Limited Company contractors, it would be worthwhile checking to see how much income you would keep using an umbrella company. Just fill out the form below and someone will be in touch to let you know.

If you think you can benefit from using an umbrella company, try the following:-

Simply Umbrella

Best Umbrella Companies for Banking Contractors / Finance Contractors

Umbrella Companies for Project Managers, Programme Managers, Interim

Do you need some professional advice on which umbrella company is right for you? Do you want to get better returns from your Umbrella Company? Fill out the form below to receive expert advice.

For all necessary business insurance, including IR35, try Business Insurance for Contractors

    Your Name (required)

    Your Email (required)

    Your Telephone (required)

    Your Daily Rate (required)

    Please Fill in Answer to Simple Quiz Question




    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.