IR35 Liability Chain
How to avoid being shackled by the IR35 liability chain
Cost-efficiency in the private sector is often achieved by delivering services through a series of interlinked entities – arrangements that keep businesses lean, but may leave them negatively exposed to changes in off-payroll working tax rules.
From April 2020, the requirement to ensure working practices are compliant with IR35, also known as the “off-payroll working rules”, is shifting from individual workers to end users of their services in the UK private sector.
Points of Interest for Contractors, Companies and Employment Agencies
- IR35 reforms will affect businesses who use contractors / consultants
- IR35 Liability chain and Employment agencies
- Practical IR35tip for contractors and employment agencies
- Address IR35 concerns prior to new off payroll legislation
- Maintain IR35 Checklist
- IR35 Liability Chain – No mass awareness Campaign by HMRC
- When dealing with an international contractor does IR35 apply?
- IR35 Liability Chain – Employment Rights
- Contractors asserting worker status for employment purposes
- Companies IR35 strategy from April 2020
- IR35 and part time consultants operating through intermediaries
- Will business costs rise as a result of IR35 legislation?
- IR35 Liability Chain – Contract Workers may increase fees
- IR35 reforms not an end to contractors / consultants
- Contractors may move to fixed price fees
- Companies should assess IR35on a case by case basis
IR35 Reforms Will Affect Businesses Who Use Contractors / Consultants
This will affect businesses who use consultants or contractors operating through intermediaries, such as personal services companies (PSCs).
As the enforcement deadline creeps closer, cracks in the business community’s preparedness for the change are starting to show.
In particular, many are anxious about how work delivered through complex chains of different entities can be made fully compliant with the new rules.
IR35 Liability Chain and Employment Agencies
One of the main areas of confusion around IR35 is what tax liability employment agencies, and those contracting with employment agencies, will face with respect to individuals they place, if those individuals are contracted through a PSC, or similar.
Unfortunately, there is no simple answer to this, as liability will be fact-specific.
While the responsibility for status assessment in these circumstances will most likely rest with the client of the employment agency, employment agencies also have the option of taking advice on the IR35 status of individuals and then passing this onto the workers and their clients.
This should ensure that the position is completely clear to all parties.
Every analysis needs to be tailored to the company, PSC or other intermediary, and the role of the individual concerned in the IR35 liability chain.
Practical IR35 Tip for Employment Agencies and Contractors
A good practical tip for employment agencies, and those contracting with them, is to make transparency a key contractual requirement.
The contract should ensure a flow of information between all concerned in the IR35 liability chain so that status determinations can be carried out and confirm who is responsible for operating PAYE.
Clear communication is key to minimising the risk of being caught out by IR35, but many struggle to put this principle into practice, especially given the lack of understanding around the new legislation and a palpable degree of resentment against it among many businesses and individuals.
Address IR35 Concerns Prior to New Off Payroll Legislation
Since IR35 is not going away, the answer is to address these concerns before the new legislation comes into force.
Every company should have policies, procedures and contractual protections (in commercial agreements) in place to ensure information can be passed smoothly up and down contract chains.
Maintain IR35 Checklist
A simple but surprisingly useful step businesses can take is to maintain IR35 checklists, which can be drawn up in consultation with advisers, or by referring to HMRC’s online “Check employment status for tax” (CEST) pages.
Several businesses and individuals have reported frustrations with using the dynamic CEST tool, however HMRC’s guidance around IR35 should be read carefully and factored into approaches to compliance.
IR35 Liability Chain – No Mass Awareness Campaign by HMRC
A number of those who stand to be affected by IR3 in the IR35 liability chain5 have expressed surprise and dismay that HMRC has not launched a mass awareness or guidance campaign about the changes to off-payroll working rules, and fear being tripped up by inaccurate hearsay.
Again, given that this is unlikely to change, the onus is on companies and individuals to check the information that has been published on HMRC’s website.
When dealing With an International Contractor Does IR35 Apply?
If work is being provided to a business by a contractor who is not UK resident, this may fall outside the remit of IR35.
For IR35 to apply, the contractor needs to be a UK tax resident.
Tax residency rules can be complex, and this is something both companies and individuals should give due consideration to when assessing their IR35 status.
Whether IR35 applies will therefore be a question of fact.
IR35 Liability Chain – Employment Rights
It has come as a shock to many individuals who provide services through intermediaries that IR35 does not have a direct correlation with their employment rights.
It does not automatically follow that if you are assessed as ‘employed’ for tax purposes under IR35, you are similarly classed as ‘employed’ for employment law purposes (although the tests for both are very similar).
Contractors Asserting Worker Status for Employment Purposes
There has however been a notable trend towards individuals asserting ‘worker status’ (for employment purposes), where they are deemed to be an employee for tax purposes.
This is because they are paying tax as employees, but have no corresponding protection under employment law, and want to align the two positions.
If large numbers of individuals begin to assert worker status, this could impact employers who may have to rethink their business models.
Companies IR35 Strategy from April 2020
Given the complications that can arise and the way tax and employment law treat individuals differently, organisations need to consider carefully how they communicate with individuals in the liability chain and, more importantly, what strategies to adopt from April 2020.
For example, they should consider whether it is it better to provide individuals with worker status, so the dichotomy between tax and employment law is eliminated; or retain two separate statuses, which can be confusing; or simply terminate the arrangement with some individuals altogether.
Any decision about changes of status need to be considered carefully, preferably in consultation with a professional adviser.
IR35 and Part Time Consultants Operating Through Intermediaries
Part time consultants operating through intermediaries, even those providing services to others at the same time, can still be caught by IR35.
When assessing an individual’s IR35 status for a particular relationship, the fact that a person’s engagements by other clients are not classed as employment is irrelevant.
A tribunal will look at the facts of the specific engagement to determine whether IR35 applies in the liability chain.
Will Business Costs Rise as a Result of IR35 Reforms?
The ultimate aim of IR35 is for HMRC to boost tax receipts from workers who are wrongly benefiting from lower tax rates charged to companies, when they should be paying National Insurance Contributions (NICs) and PAYE on earnings in the same way as regular employees.
This raises the question of where the increased tax burden will fall once IR35 comes into force in April next year.
IR35 Liability Chain – Contract Workers May Increase Fees
Contract workers may decide to increase their fees, while end users of workers’ services may push for lower rates to compensate for having to pay employer’s NICs for contractors.
How this plays out will depend on individual circumstances and is generally a commercial negotiation point, but it is likely that the overall cost of doing business in the UK will rise as a result of this legislative change.
IR35 Reforms Not an End to Contractors / Consultants
It should be stressed that the enhanced scope of IR35 is not an end to consultancy or contractor relationships.
For parties who wish to maintain a non-employment relationship, certain steps may be necessary to ensure these arrangements are not caught by IR35.
For instance, it is advisable for clients to agree fixed project fees, rather than hourly rates for time and materials.
Contracts made on a time and material basis are often viewed by HMRC and tribunals as being more akin to an employment relationship (and thus susceptible to IR35).
Contractors May Move to Fixed Price Fees
Fixed project fees, however, tend to fall more on the side of self-employment, although it should be noted that fee arrangements are just one aspect of the employment status assessment.
Additionally, companies in the liability chain should ensure that individuals do not appear in their organisation charts, have company email addresses, use company stationary or computer systems free-of-charge, as these all strengthen the argument that a worker is an employee, rather than a contractor.
Companies Should Assess IR35 on Case by Case Basis
Although it is often time-consuming and complicated, companies should always assess the impact of IR35 on a case-by-case basis, rather than adopting wide, blanket determinations for workers.
Such approaches can leave businesses open to challenges from individuals unhappy about their determinations and also from HMRC, which may disagree that all workers should be given the same classification.
This article was co-authored by Ranjit Dhindsa, employment partner, Matthew Sharp, dispute resolution lawyer and tax specialist and Ryan Hughes, legal trainee at Fieldfisher. For more information on the firm’s IR35 guidance and its employment and tax expertise, please visit the relevant pages of the Fieldfisher website.
If you know anyone else who would find this article useful, please share it with them using the social media buttons at the top and bottom of the page.
Ad – Contractor Services
When the IR35 changes were implemented in the public sector, rather than just pay the IR35 tax, most contractors inside IR35 decided to take the umbrella company route. If you are inside IR35, or caught by a blanket ban on Limited Company contractors, it would be worthwhile checking to see how much income you would keep using an umbrella company. Just fill out the form below and someone will be in touch to let you know.
If you think you can benefit from using an umbrella company, try the following:-
Do you need some professional advice on which umbrella company is right for you? Do you want to get better returns from your Umbrella Company? Fill out the form below to receive expert advice.
For all necessary business insurance, including IR35, try Business Insurance for Contractors